Grant Thornton fined £1.3m for critical failings in Sports activities Direct audits | Accountancy

Grant Thornton has been fined £1.3m for critical lapses within the basic auditing of sportswear retailer SportsDirect, the UK accounting regulator mentioned on Monday.

The findings relate to Grant Thornton’s 2016 and 2018 audits of Sports activities Direct Worldwide (SDI), often known as the Frasers Group, and the work of Philip Westerman, the associate in control of the audits.

The Monetary Reporting Council (FRC) has severely reprimanded Grant Thornton, who audited SportsDirect’s accounts because the retailer’s inventory market float in 2007, and fined Westermann £80,000.

It’s the newest embarrassment after the accountancy agency was fined £2.3m final 12 months for “gross incompetence” over its audit of collapsed cafe chain Patisserie Valerie.

The FRC investigation targeted on Grant Thornton’s failure to reveal “Supply Firm A” as a associated occasion to Mike Ashley’s Sports activities Direct within the accounts in relation to lapses within the 2016 audit.

Supply Firm A, beforehand extensively reported to be Barlin Supply Ltd, was managed by John Ashley, brother of the retail billionaire.

The FRC mentioned on Monday that Grant Thornton, the UK’s sixth-largest accountancy agency, “did not cope with the skilled skeptic administration’s assertion that Supply Firm A was not a associated occasion”.

“There are a variety of related components which ought to have prompted the respondents to think about and pursue additional issues, however they didn’t,” the FRC mentioned.

In relation to the 2018 audit, the FRC was trying into £162m of stock provision and work associated to web site gross sales, which accounted for a fifth of whole gross sales, each highlighted by Grant Thornton as areas of “vital threat”.

“The acknowledged did not get hold of ample applicable audit proof, assess whether or not the data supplied by the SDI was sufficiently dependable, or put together ample audit documentation proportionate to the danger in relation to those two areas of the audit,” the FRC mentioned.

The FRC fined Grant Thornton greater than £2m in relation to audit failures in 2016 and 2018, however this was lowered to £1.3m attributable to earlier admissions of failings. Westermann, who now not works for Grant Thornton, had his wonderful lowered from £350,000 to £80,000.

“The audit failures on this case are critical and associated to basic auditing requirements,” mentioned Jamie Symington, the FRC’s deputy govt counsel. “It’s vital that auditors pursue counterparty transactions recognized as vital audit threat with due diligence. Auditors ought to undertake a mindset {of professional} skepticism and train sound judgment based mostly on ample and correctly documented proof.

The newest FRC investigation targeted on Grant Thornton and made no findings about SportsDirect itself.

In a press release, Frasers mentioned it nonetheless believed “the disclosure of associated occasion transactions is technically appropriate” but it surely acknowledged that “additional disclosure inside the accounts could keep away from this specific side of the FRC’s investigation”.

The corporate added that there have been “no criticisms of Fraser, no points with Fraser’s historic monetary statements and no findings of undisclosed associated occasion transactions.”

Grant Thornton, who resigned as SportsDirect’s auditor in 2019 following a separate scandal over the last-minute disclosure of a €674m (£570m) tax invoice demand by Belgian authorities, mentioned he was comfortable to carry the long-running matter to a head. close to

In a press release, Grant Thornton mentioned: “Having since made vital funding within the high quality of our audits, we have now seen a marked enchancment in our outcomes and are assured that the problems recognized by the FRC’s investigations will not be reflective of our work. Do it at present.”

About the author


Leave a Comment