70-year-old girl fears she might need to promote home after neighbor sues her for £200,000

70-year-old girl fears she might need to promote home after neighbor sues her for £200,000
Written by admin
70-year-old girl fears she might need to promote home after neighbor sues her for £200,000

An award-winning gardener fears he might need to promote his house of 40 years after he was ordered to pay £200,000 to a neighbor who sued him over an apple tree that planted in his backyard.

Showing in court docket for Barbara Pilcher, 70-year-old Antoinette Williams stated she was devastated after dropping her battle to overturn the order.

Ms Williams and Ms Pilcher, 68, who reside within the cottage subsequent door, had a row over a variety of points together with the place and state of restore of the backyard fence. the aspect of her neighbour’s home and a smelly compost bin in Mrs Williams’ backyard.

However chief amongst Ms Pilcher’s complaints was that her neighbour’s tree dumped tons of of rotten apples into the orchard and attracted wasps.

Ms Pilcher, who stated she has a wasp allergy and was beforehand hospitalized after being stung, claimed she felt ‘like a prisoner’ in her house the place she couldn’t use the underside of the backyard.

70-year-old girl fears she might need to promote home after neighbor sues her for £200,000

Barbara Pilcher

A Excessive Courtroom choose has dismissed claims by apple tree proprietor Antoinette Williams (left) that Barbara Pilcher (proper) fabricated proof towards her.

The court heard that nearly 40 years ago, Mrs Williams (house on the right) moved into the £600,000 Frensham Cottage in Dunsfold, near Godalming, Surrey, while Mrs Pilcher (house on the left) bought the adjoining £500,000 three-bedroom Farleigh Cottage.  .

The court docket heard that almost 40 years in the past, Mrs Williams (home on the precise) moved into the £600,000 Frensham Cottage in Dunsfold, close to Godalming, Surrey, whereas Mrs Pilcher (home on the left) purchased the adjoining £500,000 three-bedroom Farleigh Cottage. .

She additionally accused her neighbor of assaulting her throughout an argument in a county court docket trial final yr, wherein Recorder Laurence Cohen QC dominated in her favour.

Ms Williams claimed Ms Pilcher had fabricated proof towards her to safe a bumper verdict, however her claims have been dismissed by a Excessive Courtroom choose final week.

Grandmother-of-two Williams advised MailOnline she now had no selection however to promote her £600,000 cottage within the village of Dunsfold, close to Godalming, Surrey.

She stated: ‘I am devastated that it would come to this as it has been my house for 40 years, however how can I afford this large payout?

‘I reside on a state pension alone, so now I’ve to reside like a church mouse, it is a frugal existence.

‘It is draining me financially, I’ve already spent £45-50,000 of my financial savings and it is all gone.

‘I do not actually know what I’ll do. I need to keep within the village as a result of that is the place I belong, however this has introduced me to the depths of despair.

Miss Williams, who gained prizes for her flowers as a member of the Dunsfold and Hascombe Horticultural Society, denied harassing her neighbor and inflicting her to be stung by wasps.

Aerial footage of the homes owned by Mrs Pilcher and Mrs Williams, proper half of the homes with grey roofs seen within the middle of the picture

The back garden of Mrs Pilcher's home, Farleigh Cottage, Dunsford, near Godalming, Surrey

The again backyard of Mrs Pilcher’s house, Farleigh Cottage, Dunsford, close to Godalming, Surrey

She stated: ‘She left the apples on the ground for days and naturally they might rot. It definitely wasn’t tons of.

‘When apples fell on my garden, I picked them up right away and used them for cooking or gave them to others.

‘I used to be portrayed as a faculty bully and it actually upset me. Anybody who is aware of me is aware of I am not able to performing like that.’

Ms Pilcher, who has cameras at the back and front of her property, declined to touch upon the case however admitted life along with her neighbor had been ‘tough’ and the fallout had been ‘horrendous’.

Miss Williams moved to Frensham Cottage in Dunsfold within the early Eighties, and in 2010 Miss Pilcher purchased the adjoining three-bedroom Farleigh Cottage for £500,000.

Ms Pilcher was awarded damages for harassment after a five-day trial at Central London County Courtroom final October.

Together with the apple tree, the marketing campaign contains a number of incidents, together with Miss Williams repeatedly wanting by way of Miss Pilcher’s home windows, observing her comings and goings, and ‘standing and watching’.

The choose branded Ms Williams’ habits ‘completely uncommon and disturbing’, including that the marketing campaign to look at had ‘prompted ongoing concern and misery for Ms Pilcher and her household’.

Ms Williams denied the allegations, however the choose accepted them, and stated: ‘The kind of habits alleged is paying homage to bullying habits from faculty kids making an attempt to trigger hassle and exclude one among their quantity.’

Ms Williams’ authorized representatives appealed to the Excessive Courtroom final week, arguing that the unique trial choose made a sequence of errors, leading to an ‘unfair’ verdict and a staggering prices invoice, which was a ‘important challenge’ for them.

She claimed Ms Pilcher had fabricated images tendered to the court docket displaying Williams obstructing the driveway close to her house.

Ms Williams’ authorized staff additionally complained that Ms Pilcher had solely half-hour to again up her case that her neighbor had ‘noticed’ six years of house CCTV footage.

However after a day-long listening to, Ms Williams’ bid for a brand new trial was rejected by Justice Zool, who stated there was no hope that any of her arguments would prevail.

The choice prices Mrs Williams £12,000 in damages, plus 75 per cent of the £243,000 prices invoice for the unique trial and her attorneys’ payments for her unsuccessful enchantment.

About the author


Leave a Comment